Herat cleric faces backlash over criticism of Afghan forces

By Omar

Religious scholars from Badghis province gathered February 21 to denounce remarks by Mujiburrahman Ansari, khatib of Gazar Gah Mosque in Herat. Ansari called Afghan security forces sinners for supporting the Afghan government.

HERAT -- Religious scholars, Afghan officials and Badghis and Herat residents gathered Sunday (February 21) to denounce Mujiburrahman Ansari, khatib of Gazar Gah mosque in Herat city, for his criticism of the Afghan government.

During a Friday sermon, Ansari claimed that those working for the Afghan government and those who support it are sinners.

"Those working in the system, whether civilian or military, police or army, or those who support this system have committed a great sin," he said, accusing them of being "part of all the crimes of this government".

Gathering at the Department of Hajj and Religious Affairs in Qala-e-Naw on Sunday, dozens of religious scholars from Badghis province publicly and collectively denounced Ansari's remarks.

Dozens of religious scholars gather February 21 in Qala-e-Naw, capital of Badghis province, to denounce remarks made by Mujiburrahman Ansari, khatib of Gazar Gah mosque, Herat. [Shameel Mashal/Salaam Times]

Dozens of religious scholars gather February 21 in Qala-e-Naw, capital of Badghis province, to denounce remarks made by Mujiburrahman Ansari, khatib of Gazar Gah mosque, Herat. [Shameel Mashal/Salaam Times]

"Mujiburrahman's remarks about security forces are totally rubbish and false," said Maulawi Abdul Basit Sarem, a religious scholar in Qala-e-Naw. "His statement is in contradiction with Sharia."

Ansari is a disgrace, said Maulawi Abdul Latif Sediqi, another religious scholar in Qala-e-Naw.

"Ansari is not a religious scholar, and he is not allowed to issue religious rulings," he said, describing the cleric's actions as irresponsible and un-Islamic.

"Our demand, from the government and the spiritual community of Afghanistan, is to bring Mujiburrahman to justice and punish him," Sediqi said. "He is an extremist who discredits religious scholars and Islam."

'How is this a sin?'

On Monday, more than 500 residents of Herat denounced Ansari's remarks during a gathering at the Hariwa Institute of Higher Education.

"I strongly condemn Mujiburrahman Ansari's remarks about security forces and the Afghan government," said Herat city resident Basira Safa Tahiri.

"Ansari does not have the status of a religious scholar for us, and he has always caused hatred and division," she said.

"Security forces lose blood day and night to protect Afghanistan, doing their job with integrity," she added. "How is this a sin?"

"Mujiburrahman is sitting and doing nothing and receives free food," said Tahiri, referring to gifts of food from admirers or supporters. "He has made an emotional and uninformed judgment about these heroes."

Sarajuddin Shirzai, another Herat city resident, also denounced Ansari's remarks.

"It is not acceptable to us, and we will not allow anyone to come and talk rubbish against the security forces," he said.

"Our security forces have given thousands of martyrs to protect the country," he added. "The blood of the martyred security forces is valuable to us, and we will not allow anyone to talk ill of them."

"We support the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan and our committed security forces," Shirzai said. "We will always stand with our security forces and support them wherever needed."

Ties to foreign powers

Afghan officials who spoke to Salaam Times described Ansari as a radical cleric who has ties to foreign intelligence agencies.

His comments are part of an external plot to destabilise Afghanistan, National Security Adviser Hamdullah Mohib said during a Saturday news conference.

Ansari receives support from regional intelligence agencies, and the National Directorate of Security (NDS) has been instructed to investigate the matter, he said.

Ansari will be dealt with in accordance with the law, said NDS chief Ahmad Zia Saraj.

While security forces are giving sacrifices day and night defending Afghanistan, an extremist comes at the behest of outsiders and speaks against these forces, said Herat governor Sayed Wahid Qatali.

Without using his name, Qatali accused Ansari of promoting extremism and supporting the "Islamic State of Iraq and Syria" (ISIS).

"I assure you, the people of Herat, that neither ISIS nor its tyranny is coming," he said. "Unless we are dead, they will not be able to raise their shameful black flags in this city."

"The times are gone when an extremist could come and promote extremist ideas in Herat city," he said. "People are tired of war and terror."

Support for security forces

Security forces are Muslims and sons of Afghanistan, said Maulawi Abdul Halim Sheikh-ul-Islami, who heads the Hajj and Religious Affairs Department in Badghis. "They are the real mujahideen of Afghanistan who protect the values of Islam."

"Our children give sacrifices day and night to protect the people, the country and national honour," he said. "Security forces are the real sons of this country, and all the people must support them."

The Afghan people value the sacrifices that Afghan soldiers make to protect the country, said Yagana Ahmadi, a political science student at a private university in Herat city.

"We defend our security forces as they work day and night so that we can study and live in peace," she said.

"Those who propagandise against security forces are collaborating with the Taliban and [other] enemies. They want to create distance between security forces and the public," she said.

But they will not succeed in this endeavour, she said, as "the public will stand up to them".

"From a Sharia point of view, all religious scholars in Badghis province have expressed the opinion that the police, the National Army and the NDS must be supported," said Maulawi Abdul Wahed Saberi, a religious scholar in Qala-e-Naw.

"We have supported them and will support them in the future, too," he said. "We have always supported our system, because it has legitimacy."

Do you like this article?

2 Comment

Comment Policy * Denotes required field 1500 / 1500

Mujiburrahman Ansari's remarks have been misunderstood. He never said that working in this government was a sin. He said that supporting this corrupt government was a sin. People should work in this government, but they should not approve this government in their hearts, because this government cannot protect the lives and properties of its citizens. Scholars, professors and journalists are martyred every day, but the government can do nothing to ensure the security. If the government wants to gain support of the religious scholars and the people, it should offer good services to the people, provide job opportunities for the people, and ensure security of the citizens. If the situation continues this way, people's support for this government will decrease gradually, and finally one day people will declare their support for Taliban, because there is at least security in the areas which are controlled by Taliban, the lives and property of the people are safe there, no cruelty is committed against the people, and people are not killed for the sake of a mobile phone.


It is a strange government; neither it can defend the people nor itself. They should arrest this mullah and similar other mullahs who are supported by Pakistan and Iran and who provoke the people against the Afghan security forces, they should investigate and find out with whose order they are talking so? Why they do so? They should put them in prison and fine them considering their activity in order that others would not do so. 60% Pakistani army members cannot recite the holy Quran; however, all their mullahs support their country's army and they always pray for them. An Iranian army's general was killed by Americans in Iraq, all the Iranian mullahs and even their chief mullah Khamenei were crying on his death; however, our mullahs are wild animals as they give decrees against the army men and police of their own country. It is true that there would be corruption in the government, there would be immorality, but the holy Quran says, "invite all to the way of your Lord with wisdom and kind advice". People cannot hold arms and kill each other again. We killed each other with the orders of Iran and Pakistan for 45 years. Enough is enough.