Health

25 million infected? Dubious COVID-19 numbers stoke panic in Iran

Salaam Times and AFP

image

An Iranian woman, wearing a protective face mask, walks down a street in the capital Tehran on July 22, 2020. [Atta Kenare/AFP]

TEHRAN -- Iranians are fraught with fear, anger and confusion following President Hassan Rouhani's assertion that more than half the country's population could eventually be infected with the COVID-19 coronavirus.

"Our estimate is that up to now, 25 million Iranians have been infected with this virus," Rouhani told a virus task force meeting on July 18.

Rouhani then suggested Tehran was hoping to overcome the Middle East's worst outbreak via herd immunity, rattling citizens and health officials alike.

Citing the results of a Health Ministry study, Rouhani warned that "30 to 35 million more may face infection" in the future and added that Iran had "not yet achieved herd immunity".

image

An Iranian man confronts riot police during a demonstration outside Amir Kabir University in Tehran January 11. [AFP]

That figure is drastically higher than the country's official tally of more than 291,000 COVID-19 infections and far higher than the approximately 16 million cases recorded worldwide.

Iran reported 235 new deaths from the novel coronavirus on Tuesday (July 28), a record toll for a single day in the country, taking the overall toll to 16,147.

Since Rouhani announced the massively elevated estimates, he has not mentioned them again, nor has he elaborated on his claims.

'A bit scary'

Many on Tehran's streets appeared confused or disturbed by the president's statistics.

"The way Mr. Rouhani put it, this means almost the whole population of Iran" have been or will be infected, said a 50-year-old businessman who gave his name only as Ashrafi.

Iran's population is more than 80 million.

"So, observing health protocols has been for nothing?" Ashrafi said, calling the numbers "frightening".

An art teacher named Rezayi expressed doubt that the numbers were actually so high.

"And even if they are, it's still hard to accept them given how the president has denied his statements before," she said.

She was referring to a comment Rouhani made days after the start of Iran's outbreak in February, when he said "everything will return to normal" within a few days.

Ashkan Daliri, a hairdresser in his 20s, said he considered the numbers real and "a bit scary".

The announcement was meant to make "the people face reality so that they would be scared into observing health protocols more", he said.

Growing distrust

Rouhani's shocking statement and his silence in the wake of it have Iranian officials attempting to offer their own explanations -- even as Iranians' distrust of government institutions continues to grow.

The figure of 25 million was an estimate based on research carried out in March "on about 10,000 people in 13-14 provinces", said Iranian Deputy Health Minister for Research and Technology Reza Malekzadeh.

"It's been proven so far that these people's immunity is stable, meaning that they are like those vaccinated," he told state news agency IRNA on July 20.

The figure came from serology tests, which look for antibodies and detect whether an individual has been exposed to any type of the coronavirus, not just COVID-19, said Alireza Raisi, another deputy health minister, on July 21.

Responding to a suggestion that mentioning such figures and herd immunity may alarm the public, Raisi said in a veiled criticism that "emphasising such numbers is a strategic mistake".

Rouhani's latest comments come amid a flood of disinformation about the pandemic from multiple sources.

Tehran, Moscow and Beijing have suppressed details of the coronavirus outbreak internally, censoring coverage of major outbreaks, while spreading fake news and criticising Western governments' response to the pandemic, activists say.

All three of these governments are actively promoting alternative narratives about the origins of the COVID-19 outbreak.

During the height of the coronavirus crisis, Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) made several dubious claims about the production of masks, test kits and cures for coronavirus -- none of which has proven effective.

In April, the IRGC unveiled a COVID-19 coronavirus detection device, describing it "amazing" and a "novel and singular scientific advancement" -- evoking widespread ridicule from Iranian officials and social media users alike.

Public unrest

Protests in various parts of Iran in recent weeks highlight citizens' growing anger at the regime's mismanagement of the pandemic amid the spiralling economic situation.

The regime is exacerbating Iranians' economic hardships by choosing to support proxy wars around the region -- particularly in Syria, Iraq and Yemen -- instead of investing in its own country, protesters say.

The COVID-19 coronavirus epidemic has contributed to the economic woes with a temporary shutdown of the economy and has reduced exports, leading to a sharp devaluation of the rial and rising inflation.

On July 16, police attempted to break up one such protest in Behbahan, Khuzestan Province, where protestors were shouting anti-regime slogans, much like they were in January across the country, chanting "Death to the dictator" -- a reference to Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.

The recent protests come days after Iran upheld death sentences for three men linked to deadly protests last November sparked by a hike in petrol prices.

On July 19, the regime buckled to public pressure and temporarily stayed the executions.

Do you like this article?

4 Comment
* Denotes required field Comment Policy 1500 characters remaining (1500 max)

Iranian President Rouhani is a liar. He wants to acquit himself for his country's economic weakness with these false remarks. The cause of Iran's economic downturn is the corrupt government of this country. If the current regime of Iran did not pursue terrorist policies, Iran would have been a very developed country in the region. Most countries in the world are ruined because of evil, corrupt, bigoted and cruel politicians.

Reply

The wrong policies of the government of Iran will one day take that country to economic crises, and will force the people to stand against such a cruel and oppressive system and overthrow the government. The cause of all the misfortunes of Iran is the government and system of that country because despite having all the rich mines and petroleum, Iran is still facing an economic crisis because most of the country's revenues are spent in support of terrorism.

Reply

Iran became miserable. Corona virus caused a lot of losses to all countries of the world, but these losses were more for Iran compared to other countries of the world, because more of Iran’s income comes from selling oil, but oil prices came down, and Iran sustained billions of dollars' losses.

Reply

Corona outbreak in some countries had a political cause. Some countries reported 10 times or more of the infected people in their countries in order to attract aids. To appease its internal discontent, I think the government of Iran reported many times more of the number of corona infected people, because the economy of Iranians is getting worse day by day, and people consider the government as the main cause for deteriorating the economy. Tehran is forced to link its economic weakness to COVID-19 in order to appease the noise of its people.

Reply